Hard Very Severe

Details Author : Jen Wight
Main Genre : Creative non-fiction
Other Genres : Biography/Memoir
Overall :
4
Details
Main Genre: 
Creative non-fiction
Other Genres: 
Biography/Memoir
Other Genres: 
Comedy
Other Genres: 
Travel
Other Genres: 
True life
Images
About
Summary: 

From inner-city grit to Cornish granite.

Description: 

The true tale of how climbing and story structure collided to help a city chick overcome her fear of falling and get to grips with life outside the metropolis.

Files
Average Rating
Overall:
4
Ideas:
3.5
Research:
4
Writing style:
3
Title and subtitle:
4.5
Plot and pace:
5
Characters:
4
Dialogue:
4
Professionalism:
4

User Reviews

This story gripped

Review
Manuscript: 
Review: 

This story gripped me, even though I know nothing at all about climbing. I thought the explanations were woven well into the story, so as to make readers understand what it is all about. I felt the quality of the writing was very good, though I would like to make a few comments on some parts that could be improved upon, in my personal opinion.

Some parts you seem to skip over - especially her relationship with Kai, they split up (?) and yet they keep talking to each other and in chapter three you mention that she loves him. I personally feel you need to elaborate on this, and work this out more fully into the story.

Some things I found confusing. I wasn't sure whether the protagonist was a man or a woman. You start the story with someone bragging and exagerating, and at first I thought that it was this person who was telling the story - it wasn't, but that took a moment to sink in, and left me with the feeling that the protagonist is a man (also due to the person being a climber and most climbers being male - stereotyping I know, but I'd think that most of your readers would think the same) and not till the end of chapter one did I wonder if that was indeed so - it was not.

You jump a bit within time and space, going backwards and forwards within her mind. This in itself is not a problem, but half the time, especially in chapter three, I was utterly confused as to what was going on, where she was and in what order things happened. I think this could be made clearer, especially as some of your tenses aren't used in the proper way, leaving one a bit in the lurch.

I also find you have too many characters, new names keep popping up at random and I can't keep track of them, I don't know who is who at all. Peronally I feel you could have less of them, or at least, less mentioned in name but have clearer profiles of those you do use.

Despite these things though, I feel this is a good piece of writing!

Rating
Overall rating: 
4
Ideas: 
3
Research: 
4
Writing style: 
3
Title and subtitle: 
5
Plot and pace: 
5
Characters: 
3
Dialogue: 
4
Professionalism: 
4
Details
Reviewed By : Ottilia Pochat
Reviewed on : 5th Aug 2009
Did you find this Helpful ?

Fascinating insight into

Review
Manuscript: 
Review: 

Fascinating insight into the world of climbing and a woman in her 30s wanting to change her life. But how will you keep the conceit of the story structure going for 12 chapters?

Rating
Overall rating: 
4
Ideas: 
4
Research: 
3
Writing style: 
3
Title and subtitle: 
4
Plot and pace: 
5
Characters: 
5
Dialogue: 
4
Professionalism: 
4
Details
Reviewed By : Susannah Marriott
Reviewed on : 5th Aug 2009
Did you find this Helpful ?

Login To Review

You need to either login or create a Writers account to review and upload manuscripts